PDA

View Full Version : Photog files lawsuit against LA PD


Lensmith
05-07-2007, 07:41 AM
http://www.nctimes.com/articles/2007/05/04/news/breaking/12_15_365_4_07.txt

Camerawoman files claim against Los Angeles

By: North County Times Wire Services -

SANTA MONICA - A KTTV television camerawoman filed a claim against the city today, alleging she was attacked and injured by Los Angeles police officers while covering Tuesday's immigration rights rally in MacArthur Park.

Patricia "Patti" Ballaz, 48, filed the claim for an unspecified amount of damages. Ballaz was one of several journalists who were allegedly attacked by riot police who were dispersing crowds at the conclusion of the rally. Video images from the rally show police in riot gear swinging batons and firing foam bullets, knocking protesters and reporters to the ground and even throwing a television camera to the ground.

"That police officer with full force, he's got his baton with the pointed end, and he takes it with full force and jams it forward and hits me in my right breast, which then sends me flying backward and into the ground," said Ballaz, who has worked as a photojournalist for more than 20 years.


Frank Mateljan of the City Attorney's Office said attorneys had not yet seen the claim and could not immediately comment.

A series of investigations into officers' actions are already under way, including two internal LAPD probes, a Police Commission investigation and a preliminary inquiry by the FBI.

Ballaz was badly bruised by an LAPD officer's baton, according to Kathy Pinckert of the Santa Monica law firm Greene Broillet & Wheeler, which is handling Ballaz's case.

Ballaz and KTTV reporter Christina Gonzalez were covering the rally in MacArthur Park from a police-designated area for the media, according to Ballaz's attorney, Browne Greene. Ballaz claims she was hit several times while filming the demonstrators and was eventually knocked down along with her camera.

"Once again, the LAPD has failed to comport itself properly in protecting the public," Greene said. "And as a consequence an innocent person has been injured. If the LAPD had followed its own protocols, this never would have happened. Patti Ballaz was a victim of police brutality for simply being at the right place at the wrong time. Our goal will be to take this case to trial and to hold the LAPD accountable in a court of law."

Ballaz said she suffered a wrist fracture and chest bruises and re- injured an ankle. She said she also has neck and lower-back pain.

"I'm sad about it and I'm scared and I'm angry," she said. "And I want it, I just, I want it to stop and I don't want it to ever happen to anybody else again."

The claim is a mandatory first step before Ballaz can file a civil lawsuit for personal injury against the city.

Here's a television news story about it... http://video.nbc4.tv/player/?id=100736

Buck Satan
05-07-2007, 09:20 AM
Question: If you are shooting at a rally such as this, and the police give a lawful order to disperse, what are our rights/obligation as the media? Does it go beyond what an "ordinary member of the public" has to do? Or does that vary by state?

Guess they should have "read them the Riot Act"...:)

Eightmile
05-07-2007, 11:10 AM
But did the cops give an order to disperse? I think I remember one of the articles I read said that they just went in there swinging. Then what are our rights/obligations?

Baltimore Shooter
05-07-2007, 02:30 PM
Here's an update from Yahoo:

Chief takes May Day officers off street

LOS ANGELES - Police Chief William Bratton said Sunday that up to 60 members of an elite squad that swarmed into a park and fired rubber bullets during a May Day immigration rally are no longer on the street.

Bratton said he spent the weekend viewing video of the MacArthur Park incident and he said LAPD failures were widespread with officers from the top on down culpable.

"I'm not going to defend the indefensible," Bratton told journalists groups during a meeting at a television studio in Hollywood. "Things were done that shouldn't have been done."

Journalists were among those roughed up as Metropolitan Division's B Platoon moved through MacArthur and fired 148 rubber bullets to break up what had been a peaceful and lawful immigration rally.

Police said they moved in after rocks and bottles were thrown at them by 30 to 40 agitators, he said.

The Metropolitan Division is the city's premier police squad, made up of experienced officers who have extensive training in crowd control.

Bratton said up to 60 members of the Metro's B Platoon are no longer in the field. Additionally, he said, some officers will "in all likelihood" not return to the Metropolitan Division.

"Some of this will be career-impacting," Bratton said, adding that imposition of permanent discipline will await completion of the Police Department investigation.

Journalist organizations asked why officers ignored LAPD policies toward the news media worked out after reporters were assaulted during the 2000 Democratic National Convention.

A 2002 agreement called for designation of a safe spot for reporters covering news events. LAPD spokeswoman Mary Grady acknowledged reporters were not given "a designated safe spot" at MacArthur Park.

"There appears to have been here a failure to communicate," Press Photographers Association local president John McCoy said.
--------------------------------------------------------
Link - http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070507/ap_on_re_us/immigration_rally_clash
Warren

BluesDaddy
05-07-2007, 03:26 PM
Warning: Hijack...
Ballaz's attorney, Browne Greene.
????
'course, we have a lawyer here named Kelly Greene.


Now, back to your regular discussion....

cameragod
05-07-2007, 03:26 PM
I always thought it was ironic to the extreme that cops used to call training with a long baton “PR 13” training. Maybe the guy in charge said “Lets give the media some good PR” and they got the wrong meaning? :D

Chronically Confused
05-07-2007, 09:29 PM
did you see the officer rip the camera from the photojournalist's hands and throw it to the ground?! That's just not right!

marv3
05-08-2007, 12:54 AM
After the 2000 DNC here in LA, They passed a law that gives the media the right to cover riots or unrest even though there's an order given to disperse. Now thoughs metro cops forgot that than and even now. Dealing with the media in the lapd training book is a scratch note. Every photographer here in town is MAD AS HELL! I had alot of friends get hurt. One of my good buddies is still out with injuries. Yes i'm pissed! Every time I edit that footage it get a little harder for me to do my job. Just wanted to vent.

Dave Putnam
05-08-2007, 02:58 AM
Heads have started to roll at L.A.P.D. (http://abclocal.go.com/kabc/story?section=local&id=5283246) and it's looking like more will follow.